Back in 2023, Kaathal: The Core received widespread popularity of being a pathbreaking film that explored queer identity, the emotional challenges faced by individuals navigating their sexuality, the burden of secrecy, and the societal pressures they endure. It also make clear the emotional toll such situations tackle their spouses. Featuring Mammootty and Jyothika within the lead roles, the film addressed these complex issues with sensitivity and nuance. While it was praised by each critics and audiences for its portrayal of a marginalized community, it’s price noting that Kaathal may not have been as revolutionary as some imagine—especially compared to the 2013 film Mumbai Police, which featured Prithviraj Sukumaran in the same, yet earlier and bolder, role.
Why Kaathal: The Core Is Not as Groundbreaking as It Seems Initially
Kaathal: The Core was released at a time when public acceptance of queer identities had grown relatively stronger in Kerala. There was a noticeable shift in societal attitudes, with many Malayalis appearing more open and the state government showing surface-level support for the LGBTQ+ community. The film leaned more towards artistic expression than industrial appeal, aiming to thoughtfully portray the inner conflicts and challenges faced by individuals grappling with their identity—something that becomes evident through its narrative and tone.
The Societal Changes in Kerala Have Been Significant
When Mumbai Police was released in 2013, it arrived at a time when the Supreme Court had re-criminalized same-sex relationships, and societal acceptance was significantly lower. Even today, being a part of the LGBTQ+ community in Kerala comes with its share of challenges. Nonetheless, advocating for queer rights is now viewed with more openness and is usually considered a courageous stance—something that wasn’t the case back then.
Trending
Mumbai Police: Why Was It Groundbreaking?
By Mollywood standards, Mumbai Police was a mainstream industrial thriller that didn’t seem like aiming for awards or delivering a social message. Yet, it broke ground just by featuring a young lead actor within the role of a closeted queer man—something almost unheard of on the time. The film even depicted moments of emotional and physical intimacy between the characters, a daring move in comparison with Kaathal: The Core, which selected a more restrained approach.
That said, it stays notable that a veteran actor like Mammootty took on such a layered role in Kaathal. But as noted earlier, society is more open to such narratives today. Even now, Mumbai Police continues to surprise recent viewers. One Reddit user wrote: “In theatres, our jaws dropped. We didn’t see the twist coming, not even from 100 miles away. You might have to recollect—this was 11 years ago. LGBTQ+ representation in cinema was almost nonexistent back then. The impact wouldn’t have been the identical if it released today.”
MUMBAI POLICE WAS CRAZYYYYYYY
byu/waitresfromratatoing inMalayalamMovies
7 years of ‘Mumbai Police’: When Prithviraj-Rosshan Andrrews combo made Indian cinema’s first gay hero
byu/TejasNair inKerala
What stands out in each Kaathal: The Core and Mumbai Police is their departure from stereotypical portrayals of queer characters, often reduced to comic relief in mainstream cinema. In Mumbai Police, the protagonist is depicted as masculine and layered, breaking away from typical cinematic molds. While Kaathal went on to win several prestigious awards and gained widespread recognition, Mumbai Police didn’t receive the identical level of acclaim on the time. It stays, in some ways, an underappreciated trailblazer.
Try trailer here:
For more such updates, take a look at Down South
Must Read: The RajaSaab: Malavika Mohanan Stuns In Pristine White Saree In First Look From Prabhas’ Film
Follow Us: Facebook | Instagram | Twitter | YouTube | Google News